(Crédit: Marcin Mazur)

The Holy Land

“Where can we go? After all, this is our home”

Israel’s wall in the Cremisan Valley: The hopes of  Beit Jala Christians are again diminished


The hopes of Beit Jala Christians , a town  neighbouring Bethlehem, have again diminished. Israel’s supreme court has now dismissed their lawyers’ most recent petitions. The aim was to force the Israeli army to disclose the precise course of the wall in the Cremisan Valley, which is part of Beit Jala, before construction commenced.


The plaintiffs, Christian families and members of Catholic orders, wanted to use this  to stop the army creating a situation on the ground in the agricultural area which could not be appealed against. The judges did emphasize the possibility of an appeal. But with the rejection of the petition, continued work to close the gap connecting the sections of wall between Israel and Palestine has become possible.

Mgrs. William Shomali "People feel very frustrated and depressed. "
Mgrs. William Shomali “People feel very frustrated and depressed.”


“This dismissal has weakened their trust in the justice and will motivate some people to sell and leave,” Auxiliary Bishop William Shomali explained in an interview with the international Catholic pastoral charity Aid to the Church in Need. In the Latin Patriarchate of Jerusalem he is responsible for the Palestinian areas. As for the promise to allow owners to have full access to their land, it is not enough. It means the owners can use their land to plant grapes and olives but not to construct a home. The access itself may be denied in the future, since the land behind the wall will be part of Jerusalem. Going there needs a permit and permits can be denied,” the Bishop said.


The legal dispute between the Christian landowners and the Israeli army has been dragging on since 2006. The proceedings are being followed closely by the media and also by diplomats from the whole world stationed in Israel. Pope Francis has also intervened. But minor successes over the past year have ultimately given way to disillusion. Israel’s supreme court as the final arbiter announced that the army could build – on Palestinian soil.  As a result, 58 Christian families will lose their land where the wall is and sooner or later or will only have limited access to it. Israel justified the planned route by quoting security reasons and defence against terrorism, and it talks of this being a temporary measure. But the Palestinians regard the course of the wall as a state-organised land grab. They talk of the “annexation wall.”


In actuality, the barrier, which meanders across more than 700 kilometers between Israeli and Palestinian areas, has about eighty per cent of its structure on Palestinian land, and not on the Israeli border.

“The land has belonged to us for generations”


In August of last year, the excavators advanced in the valley(Credit: Society Saint Yves).
In August of last year, the excavators advanced in the valley (Credit: Society Saint Yves).

In August of last year, the excavators advanced in the valley. Ancient olive trees uprooted: The wall – already growing out of the soil. “I have to date lost fifteen olive trees because of the wall. They were many hundreds of years old. It makes my heart bleed,” said Mr Nahmi. “And they intend to take even more from us.” The elderly gentleman, an Orthodox Christian from Beit Jala, is directly affected by the construction of the wall. He doesn’t think much of the agricultural gates in the wall which the army intends to install for the farmers. “This hasn’t worked in the past. For some security reason or other people are then stopped from entering. Regardless of whether they have permission or not to take heavy agricultural machinery and workers across to the fields located on the Israeli side. The fact is that our land is lost. The Israelis still apply Ottoman law by which private land passes into state ownership if it hasn’t been cultivated for ten years.”


His nephew Xavier, a Chilean-born Palestinian, agrees with him. He had very consciously decided to return to the home of his forefathers. The young Catholic said: “For four years we have celebrated  Holy Mass and prayed every Friday in the olive groves so that we will be spared what is now happening. I said to our critics that prayer and non-violent resistance pay off. But what can I say now?”


Mrs Ilham is also affected by the planned wall. “It’s very difficult for us. A catastrophe,” the teacher from Beit Jala said. “The land has belonged to us for generations. It’s not only about the fruit that we grow there. It’s about our history, our bond with our homeland which is being taken from us.” This seventy-year-old lady understands it when young people from Beit Jala think about emigrating. “But where can we go? After all, this is our home. Everywhere else we are strangers.”


Priests saying mass in cremisan valley, August 2015 (Credit: Saint-Yves Society).
Priests saying mass in Cremisan valley, August 2015 (Credit: Saint-Yves Society).



















By Oliver Maksan, ACN International
Adapted by Amanda Bridget Griffin, ACN Canada


Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts